Top Legal Cases of 2020

On January 8, 2020, Lawrence B. Ryan pleaded guilty in the Eastern District of Virginia, Norfolk Division, to conspiracy to illegally distribute controlled substances and introduce mislabeled drugs into interstate traffic with intent to defraud or mislead. Ryan pleaded guilty and admitted that from 2007 to 2010, he illegally authorized more than 158,000 drug orders placed by customers through prescription drug buying websites, including Fioricet, a drug containing the controlled substance butalbital. The sites were affiliated with a large internet pharmacy organization called RX Limited. Ryan, then a licensed physician in Virginia, was paid $2 per order of medication. He admitted that he had no personal contact with customers, who themselves chose the type, strength and quantity of medication they ordered. The verdict is scheduled for April 6, 2020. Here are some of the hot arguments that await the Supreme Court in 2020. Last month, the court heard a third challenge to the Affordable Care Act (ABA).

Protesters argued that the original design of the ACA depended on the requirement that most people purchase insurance as well as a tax penalty for non-compliance. When President Donald Trump`s Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 set the individual warrant penalty at $0, protesters argued that the individual warrant was no longer a tax and therefore illegal, which should result in the entire health care law being struck down. Court dismisses Indivior`s request to drop charges of illicit marketing of opioids U.S. v. Indivior Inc. et al. Last April, the court ruled that the jury`s unanimous verdicts violated the Sixth Amendment`s right to a jury trial. However, this decision only applied to future cases.

Earlier this month, judges debated whether the new April rule should apply retroactively to prisoners in Louisiana and Oregon who were unanimously convicted. The judges heard the case of Thedrick Edwards, a Louisiana prisoner who was convicted by a non-unanimous jury. Edwards` lawyers argued that he was entitled to a new trial given the April ruling declaring such sentences unconstitutional. 9. In July 2018, the District Court issued a permanent injunction against Todd and Patty Meech Dairy Farm and its owners, Todd Meech and Patty Meech, permanently prohibiting defendants from distributing adulterated meat under the Food, Drugs and Cosmetics Act. The United States alleged in a complaint filed in February 2018 that the defendants failed to comply with laws designed to protect consumers from consuming foods containing new veterinary drugs beyond legal limits. According to the complaint, laboratory tests conducted by the U.S. Department of Agriculture revealed drug residues in the liver of one of the defendant`s cows sold for slaughter.

The complaint alleged that an FDA inspection confirmed that the defendants had not recorded any information about the dosage administered, route of administration, withdrawal period for meat, or usable date for meat. The consent order requires defendants to establish and implement a quarantine or separation system that ensures easy differentiation between medical and non-traded animals and prevents defendants from selling or supplying animals with new residues of illegal veterinary drugs in their edible tissues for food slaughter. On August 19, 2020, Shmuel Gali pleaded guilty to conspiracy, conspiracy to launder money, securities fraud and counting false mileage related to an odometer fraud scheme involving more than 690 used vehicles and approximately $4.1 million in losses related to consumer fraud. Gali pleaded guilty and admitted that he and his brother Chaim Gali developed a system from 2006 to 2011 to deceive consumers by distorting the mileage of used vehicles. As part of this scheme, the Galis used fictitious dealer names to purchase high-mileage vehicles, changed odometer and vehicle titles, received “clean” titles from Pennsylvania that reflected the wrong mileage, and sold the vehicles at auction in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. Gali was extradited from Israel in December 2019; His sentencing is scheduled for December 10. His brother has already pleaded guilty and is awaiting his verdict. 29. In April 2021, Omar Cuzcano Marroquin pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit mail and wire transfer fraud related to a number of Peruvian call centers that used internet calls to contact Spanish-speaking consumers in the United States to threaten and defraud them. Cuzcano admitted that he ran and supervised call centers operated under the program, in which the defendants and their associates falsely claimed to be lawyers, court officials, federal agents and representatives of a so-called “misdemeanor court.” According to court documents, Cuzcano and his co-conspirators falsely told the victims that they were contractually obligated to pay for and receive products, and that they had caused legal problems for themselves and others by allegedly not doing so. The appellants also falsely threatened victims with lawsuits, negative credit report ratings, imprisonment or immigration consequences if they did not immediately pay for the allegedly delivered products and handling charges. Thousands of vulnerable victims paid money to the conspirators because of these threats, which cost victims in the United States more than $1 million in losses.

Cuzcano is the first of the five defendants in the case to plead guilty. Two other accused remain in Peru and are awaiting extradition. The case is before U.S. District Judge Robert N. Scola. On April 21, 2020, the Department of Justice announced that Chipotle Mexican Grill had agreed to pay a $25 million fine to solve criminal charges related to foodborne illness outbreaks that affected more than 1,100 people between 2015 and 2018. Information filed on the same day accused the company of two food adulteration offenses in violation of the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act. The violations were primarily due to norovirus outbreaks related to non-compliance with food safety protocols by employees of company-owned restaurants. The fine, the highest ever imposed in a food safety case, is part of a deferred prosecution agreement that allows Chipotle to avoid conviction if it complies with an enhanced food safety program.

On September 3, 2020, U.S. District Judge Robert N. Scola sentenced Johnny Hidalgo to 100 months in prison and three years of supervised release for overseeing the Peruvian Everglades Call Center to conduct a fraud and extortion scheme against U.S. consumers. As part of his guilty plea, Hidalgo admitted that he and other residents of Peru`s Everglades had called victims in the United States claiming to be lawyers or government officials. The appellants falsely claimed that victims did not pay or receive certain shipments of products and that victims owed thousands of dollars in fines as a result.